
If you do not know Pokémon, you are living under Mount Fuji. Yet if you know Digimon, you are “alone on this bro 🙁”. I am exaggerating, but as a manchild who grew up with both franchises in the mid-2000s, there is a surprising dominance of Pokémon’s popularity over Digimon’s despite both franchises encompassing identical game and film media premises around their driving monster taming focus. It is even surprising that a franchise overshadowed by such a monstrous presence since 1997 has bested extinction to this day. The timing could not be any better either. Digimon released a brand new game that is lauded by long-time fans as one of the best Digimon Story titles ever released, apparently so good that even Pokémon loyalists are warming up to it. Has The Pokémon Company finally met its match?
Just like its predecessors, Digimon Story: Time Stranger is a Japanese Role-Playing creature collector set in an alternate future Tokyo where sentient digital monsters called Digimon exist. The story itself is a new part of the franchise’s multiverse that is separate from older media, so be rest assured that even a newbie to the franchise is not an alien. Aside from the typical multiverse shenanigans, the story makes full use of what we know as time travel.

As a literal stranger across time, the time-travelling protagonist uses anime technology, spiritual enlightenment, and the power of friendship to travel to the past and save humanity from impending extinction by resolving related disasters. In an effort to save mankind, they discover that the source of the calamity originated from the Digital World of Illiad, where the Digimon who reside there are locked in a massive turf war so intense, that it breached a portal to the material world. Now that is what I call an anime plot.

To save the world, battles are waged in a turn-based format, just like Pokémon. Unlike Pokémon’s typical one-on-one battles however, Time Stranger operates a 3-member tag team with 3 reserves and the occasional guest Digimon, prioritising the power of friendship over individualism. Plus, all Digimon have unique battle and victory animations which tickle my childish mind in a way that Pokemon does not.

But I believe a more pivotal aspect to enjoying a creature collector is the breadth of its monster designs. In my opinion, this is where Digimon definitely triumphs over Pokémon. But of course, seeing is believing…

Can’t leave out poop either.

Still, no game is perfect, and this one certainly is far from game-changing. A big one that personally rubs me the wrong way is the gameplay progression for digivolution, which is frankly tedious and irritating. To elaborate, the penultimate Mega Digimon are gatekept behind the agent rank which require early and mid-game sidequests that expedite its growth, and missing even just 4 can prevent access to Mega Digivolution right up until the endgame unless you knew to complete them all immediately in the first place. While it is certainly doable to complete a first playthrough without any Megas, it is a shame that they are treated more like replayability bait instead of the cherry on top.

Despite this, these sidequests are still absolutely worthwhile, especially for long-time Digimon fans. Some contain Easter eggs paying homage to iconic characters. For instance, you might be able to witness a secret cutscene of an iconic Digimon and his fellow comrades assisting you in the final boss battle if you complete their respective sidequests. So when all is said and done, I still had a great time with a beloved childhood franchise that I hold dear to my heart. Does it overcome Pokémon? Not yet, but Team Rocket should ready their Pokéballs for a fierce clash with the Digidestined.

Pros: So far the most complete collection of monsters of any base Digimon game, excluding DLC. Together with addictive turn-based combat, unpredictable evolution lines, and high-quality animations means hundreds of hours of adventure.
Cons: Uninspiring story premise and perplexing progression gatekeeping can hinder the enjoyment of an otherwise fun and spontaneous narrative.
Verdict: If you’re looking for a good time or are a fan, this is for you. Just make sure those side quests are not left out…