Thu. Nov 19th, 2026

Not Quite a Showstopper, Still Worth the Applause: Taylor Swift’s Album The Life of a Showgirl (2025)

I love Taylor Swift. I should make that clear from the beginning – she has been the soundtrack to my life for over a decade. But having her music on repeat does not mean every track makes the playlist.

Released in October 2025 after the Eras Tour and her engagement to Travis Kelce, The Life of a Showgirl (TLOAS) trades the melancholy of Swift’s recent work for a brighter take on fame, online toxicity and love.

“Bangers.” That is the word Swift used to describe all 12 songs of her twelfth studio album. It also reunites her with pop masterminds Max Martin and Shellback. With this trio back together, expectations were high. However, the album turned out to be different from what anyone expected it to be.

Ahead of the album coming out, Swift released the cover on social media. (Instagram: @taylorswift)

The album has been a statistical success – it achieved the most first-week sales in history, selling 3.5 million album sales and charting #1 on the Billboard 200.

Despite this astonishing run atop the charts, the pendulum of public opinion always swings violently following a new release from Swift. TLOAS is no exception, with critics far from unified in their praise.

Some critics have embraced the album. Rolling Stone awarded TLOAS a glistening five stars, while The BBC deemed it “a triumph,”. Variety praised its “contagiously joyful” sound. That joy has also resonated with fans. “I feel like right now in the world, we need this pop-princess energy of infectious joy,” said Ellie Goldberg, a junior theatre arts student.

The visuals of this era truly delivered. (Credit: Mert and Marcus/Republic Records)

I can understand the enthusiasm because Swift delivers on some of her promises. “Opalite” immediately makes you want to groove and dance, while “The Fate of Ophelia” combines storytelling with a modern pop sound, making it an excellent choice for a single. My favourite, however, is the soft-focus ballad “Ruin the Friendship,” which arguably brings us back to her Fearless (2008) and Speak Now (2010) eras. Meanwhile, the raunchy lyrics and sexual innuendos of “Wood” reveals Swift’s playful side – and I’m here for it.

Together, these songs show why the album remains so enjoyable, even if it doesn’t rank among Swift’s strongest work.

The Midland Reporter-Telegram captures this balance well, saying the album “mostly delivers on its promise of up-tempo pop bangers.” Although it “isn’t as seismic” as Swift’s previous releases, it still offers “glitz and glamour with humanity and humour.”

But not everyone is ready to hand out Grammy awards. The Financial Times says it “lacks sparkle”. Sputnick Music concurred it was “like a mashup of every possible Swift musical trope tossed into a blender.” The Guardian’s Alexis Petridis wrote, “it isn’t terrible: it’s just nowhere near as good as it should be given Swift’s talents.” Harsh? Maybe. But when Taylor Swift is the benchmark, the bar is always sky-high, particularly when it comes to songwriting.

Swift has long been commended for her ability to write complex and meaningful lyrics, turning a simple sentiment into a genius line. Despite the album’s catchy hooks and bouncy melodies, it lacks some of the lyrical depth and metaphors that give listeners something to ponder. Instead, Swift leans on internet slang and cringeworthy phrases that feel out of place.

For me, the most disappointing example is “Eldest Daughter.” Within the Swiftie fandom, track five has long been synonymous with heart-wrenching, emotional ballads. However, “Eldest Daughter” never reaches the emotional heights that were expected. Beats Per Minute suggests it sometimes sounds like a collection of demos without a strong thematic thread.

Sequins, feathers and full showgirl mode: Taylor Swift in promotional imagery for The Life of a Showgirl. Photograph: Mert Alas and Marcus Piggott.

The songs are easy to listen to, but they lack the spark I anticipated. Style Magazine agrees that the production is technically sound but often feels generic—“almost like something an AI could have churned out.” While Fan-culture researcher Georgia Carroll argues that the production almost makes listeners forget that the lyrics are not up to scratch, and I agree.

I can only compare Taylor Swift with herself, and perhaps that is part of the problem. With 12 albums to her name, it is neither realistic nor fair to expect her to outdo herself every time.

I don’t think The Life of a Showgirl is the greatest thing Swift has ever done. Personally, I skip a few songs and that is fine. It is slightly underwhelming but still entertaining, even if it lacks the substance many hoped for. This showgirl still deserves her applause.

By Issy

Related Post