Source: IMP Awards, Image Copright: Disney & The Refinery
Camp Rock 3 premiered on the Disney Channel on the 13th of August, rounding out the franchise sixteen years since the last sequel, Camp Rock 2: Final Jam, and almost twenty years since the first Camp Rock movie aired in 2008. The film has garnered mixed reviews, with fans and critics alike finding it to be either a wholesome return of a much-loved franchise, or just the latest example of Disney cashing in with another soulless reboot. And I can’t say I totally disagree with the latter.
Camp Rock 3’s obsession with nostalgia is arguably its most glaring issue. Not even five minutes into its 92-minute run time, which is the shortest run time of all three movies, and Camp Rock 3 has rushed through the most recognisable 60 seconds of ‘Brand New Day’, referenced lyrics from ‘This Is Me’, shown the ‘Camp Rock Stomp’, had the supposed antagonist and her lackeys dance to ‘Can’t Back Down’ before wrapping up with the Jonas Brothers reprising their roles as the in-universe boyband, Connect 3. And it doesn’t end there, the entire movie feels like it is racing to get to the next reference as quickly as possible, sacrificing its pacing and characters in the process.
Sage Scott, played by Liamani Segura, suffers the most as the supposed new protagonist of the franchise. Many agree, myself included, that Segura is one of the best things about the movie as she is an extremely talented singer and her portrayal of Sage is effortlessly endearing. Unfortunately, compared to Mitchie Torres, played by Demi Lovato and the protagonist of the previous films, Sage feels flat and underdeveloped in her journey from being someone that thinks scheduling 20 minutes a day to practise ‘being authentic’ will help her win the Final Jam to realising that fame and success don’t matter if you don’t have friends by your side. Sage’s development just doesn’t hit as hard as it could without seeing her life outside of the camp, like how she supposedly broke up her and her brother’s band in order to prioritise her own quest for fame. It would have been great to actually see that happen, but instead we are only told about it through passive aggressive conversations and adorkable info-dumping.
The first Camp Rock isn’t exactly a master class in writing complex and nuanced characters, it does successfully make use of basic narrative techniques like ‘show don’t tell’. Camp Rock demonstrates how Mitchie is just your typical, slightly awkward teenage girl who is desperate to express herself through her music before she even arrives at the camp through a montage of her trying on different outfits and flipping through her song journal as ‘Who Will I Be’ plays over the scene. While this a pretty unsubtle example of ‘show, don’t tell’, it still trusts the audience to infer who Mitchie is without the needing it to be blurted out in an exposition dump disguised as quirky rambling.
Funnily enough, Camp Rock 3 even features a scene where Milo Manheim’s character instructs the campers on how to be better songwriters through the use of ‘show, don’t tell’. Unsurprisingly, fans were quick to call out the irony of the scene, saying that movie should have listened to its own advice considering its flagrant lack of subtlety and an overreliance on conveying information via exposition.
Ultimately, Camp Rock 3 is an upbeat albeit slightly cringey return to the iconic Camp Rock universe, but I doubt anyone truly expected it to be any different. Despite the decision to make another Camp Rock movie almost two decades since the franchise first ended leaving many fans feeling like this sequel is over ten years too late and that it is more like a bootleg than a real continuation, the movie has still proven popular with families. Camp Rock 3 achieves exactly what it sets out to do, which is be a simple but fun movie with a little something for new and old fans alike, even if it also happens to be the latest example of Disney exhuming anything and everything in order to make a quick buck.
